• Brass Tally Mark Keychain
  • Brass Tally Mark Keychain
  • Brass Tally Mark Keychain
1 3

Best Engravings

Personalized Brass Tally Mark Keychain — Engraved 21st Anniversary Gift

Personalized Brass Tally Mark Keychain — Engraved 21st Anniversary Gift

$28.00 USD
$28.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Personalize your engraving 2 lines max · 11 characters per line
Font
Live preview
Your text here

Preview is a guide — please double-check spelling. Final piece is hand-engraved to order.

Order today → ships by soon

  • Handmade in the USA
  • 6,000+ 5-star reviews
  • Free shipping over $35
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee

Twenty-one years is a number worth displaying. This handcrafted brass keychain wears every one of them — 21 tally marks engraved across the front, a striking count of a relationship that has truly stood the test of time.

Why couples love it:

  • Twenty-one marks, beautifully rendered. The engraved tally marks fill the front of the keychain with meaning — a visual testament to two decades and a year together.
  • Warm, rich brass. Brass develops a gorgeous natural patina over time, so this keepsake only gets more character the longer it's carried.
  • Personalize the back for +$5. Add up to 2 lines of 11 characters on the back — a name, a date, or words that round out the story the front already starts.

Details: Brass · handcrafted keychain · 21 tally marks engraved on front · optional back engraving +$5 (2 lines × 11 characters)

How to personalize: Add your message for the back — up to 2 lines, 11 characters each. Choose Script, Sans Serif, or explore hundreds of Google Fonts with a live preview at checkout.

Handmade & shipped fast: Made by hand in Fort Collins, Colorado and shipped in 1–2 business days. Personalized items are final sale — each engraving is checked before it leaves our hands.

A gift for the couple who has built something truly rare — and wants a beautiful reminder of it.

Materials

Available in copper, brass, and aluminum.

Shipping & Returns

Ships via USPS from Fort Collins, CO. Personalized orders ship in about 2 business days. Returns are not accepted on personalized products.

View full details

How it works

  1. 1
    Choose your piece

    Pick your metal, size, and any options.

  2. 2
    Personalize it

    Type your engraving and watch it appear in the live preview — pick from Script, Sans Serif, or 100+ fonts.

  3. 3
    We engrave & ship

    Hand-engraved to order in Fort Collins, Colorado and shipped in 1–2 business days.

Frequently asked questions

How long until my order ships?
Every piece is made to order and ships in 1–2 business days via USPS from our Colorado studio.
Will the engraving fade or rub off?
No — it's laser-engraved directly into the metal, so it's permanent and won't fade, peel, or wash away.
What fonts can I choose?
Script, Sans Serif, or 100+ Google fonts — all shown in a live preview so you see exactly how your engraving will look before you order.
Can I engrave both sides?
Yes — choose the both-sides option where it's offered (it's included free on heart tags and wallet cards).
Can I return a personalized item?
Because each piece is custom-engraved, it's final sale — but we double-check every engraving against your order before it ships, and we stand behind our work.