• Brass Tally Mark Keychain
  • Brass Tally Mark Keychain
  • Brass Tally Mark Keychain
1 3

Best Engravings

Personalized Brass Tally Mark Keychain — Engraved 21st Anniversary Gift

Personalized Brass Tally Mark Keychain — Engraved 21st Anniversary Gift

$28.00
$28.00
Sale Sold out
Personalize your engraving2 lines max · 11 characters per line
Font
Live preview
Your text here

Preview is a guide. Please double-check spelling. Final piece is hand-engraved to order.

Order today, ships in 1-2 business days

  • 6,000+ five-star reviews on Etsy since 2019
  • Handmade in the USA Fort Collins, Colorado
  • Permanent engraving Laser-engraved, will not fade
  • Free shipping over $35 USPS, 1-2 day turnaround

Twenty-one years is a number worth displaying. This handcrafted brass keychain wears every one of them — 21 tally marks engraved across the front, a striking count of a relationship that has truly stood the test of time.

Why couples love it:

  • Twenty-one marks, beautifully rendered. The engraved tally marks fill the front of the keychain with meaning — a visual testament to two decades and a year together.
  • Warm, rich brass. Brass develops a gorgeous natural patina over time, so this keepsake only gets more character the longer it's carried.
  • Personalize the back for +$5. Add up to 2 lines of 11 characters on the back — a name, a date, or words that round out the story the front already starts.

Details: Brass · handcrafted keychain · 21 tally marks engraved on front · optional back engraving +$5 (2 lines × 11 characters)

How to personalize: Add your message for the back — up to 2 lines, 11 characters each. Choose Script, Sans Serif, or explore hundreds of Google Fonts with a live preview at checkout.

Handmade & shipped fast: Made by hand in Fort Collins, Colorado and shipped in 1–2 business days. Personalized items are final sale — each engraving is checked before it leaves our hands.

A gift for the couple who has built something truly rare — and wants a beautiful reminder of it.

Materials

Available in copper, brass, and aluminum.

Shipping & Returns

Ships via USPS from Fort Collins, CO. Personalized orders ship in about 2 business days. Returns are not accepted on personalized products.

View full details

How it works

  1. 1
    Choose your piece

    Pick your metal, size, and any options.

  2. 2
    Personalize it

    Type your engraving and watch it appear in the live preview. Pick Script, Sans Serif, or one of 100+ fonts.

  3. 3
    We engrave & ship

    Engraved to order in Fort Collins, Colorado and shipped in 1-2 business days.

Frequently asked questions

How long until my order ships?
Every piece is made to order and ships in 1-2 business days via USPS from our Colorado studio.
Will the engraving fade or rub off?
No. It's laser-engraved right into the metal, so it's permanent and won't fade, peel, or wash away.
What fonts can I choose?
Script, Sans Serif, or 100+ Google fonts. They all show in the live preview, so you see how your engraving will look before you order.
Can I engrave both sides?
Yes, wherever the both-sides option is offered. It's included free on heart tags and wallet cards.
Can I return a personalized item?
Each piece is engraved just for you, so it's final sale. We check every engraving against your order before it ships, and we stand behind our work.